The Hand in the Room

Share this post:

Street sign pointing to The Knesset in Hebrew, Arabic, and English on a clear day with trees in the background.

Israel's documented interference in Canadian democracy — and what the asterisks are hiding. A report published on May 13, 2026, by CJPME (Canadians for Justice and Peace in the Middle East)

The Asterisks in the Parliamentary Report

There is a sentence in Canada’s own parliamentary security report that most Canadians have never read, because most Canadians do not know it exists.

It describes the primary perpetrators of transnational repression against ethnocultural communities in Canada. Six countries were identified. Three names are visible in the public document. Three are replaced with asterisks—redacted at the direction of the Prime Minister’s office, on grounds of national security, national defence, and international relations.

The Prime Minister of Canada removed the names of countries that his own government's security apparatus identified as targeting Canadians on Canadian soil. The justification: disclosure would be injurious to international relations. Not to the safety of Canadians. To the relationships Canada has with the governments doing the targeting.

That is the sentence this piece begins with. Because everything that follows is a description of what is behind the asterisks—documented, sourced, and confirmed in part by Canada’s own government—and what it means that the asterisks are still there.

Foreign Interference, by Definition

In October 2023, the Israeli consulate on Bloor Street in Toronto secretly commissioned an opinion poll. The poll used biased language designed to sway results in support of Israel’s military conduct in Gaza. It was conducted by a Toronto public relations firm, Aurora Strategies Global, without disclosing that the client was the Israeli consulate. According to The Breach’s investigation, Liberal Party insiders—members of a WhatsApp group called “Lib Friends of Israel”—were told the poll was done on behalf of the Israeli consulate and discussed routing it to the Prime Minister’s Office before its public release.

This is the definition of foreign interference as written in Canada’s own Countering Foreign Interference Act: a foreign state attempting to covertly influence decisions or outcomes, using deception, through Canadian proxies. The Canadian government confirmed elements of the allegations. No accountability followed.

Between 2019 and 2021, Israel’s Ministry of Justice secretly hired a Toronto law firm to intervene in a Canadian federal court dispute over the labelling of wines from illegal Israeli settlements in the occupied West Bank. The firm was paid to prepare talking points for use in discussions with Canadian authorities and attend court hearings on Israel’s behalf while remaining, in The Breach’s words, “publicly undetected.” Canada ultimately appealed the federal court ruling that had found “Product of Israel” labels on settlement goods misleading, false, and deceptive—the position Israel’s covert intervention had sought. To this day, Canadian regulations treat settlement goods as if they were produced inside Israel rather than in occupied Palestinian territory.

The Exigent Foundation, an Ontario-based organization, ran at least eight propaganda trips to Israel for right-wing journalists and media personalities. At least two of those trips, in late 2025, were secretly funded by Israel’s Ministry of Foreign Affairs — nearly $175,000 CAD approved without disclosure to participants or the public. Many of those participants published articles about their experiences without disclosing any financial connection to the Israeli government. One of them, a federal lobbyist contracted by the Jewish National Fund, is now promoting a book about what he calls a “hidden hand” behind pro-Palestinian organizing in Canada.

The hand, it turns out, was in the room.

The $730 Million Campaign — and the Charter It Is Closing

The Jerusalem Post:Israel’s government’s 2026 state budget reserves $730 million USD for overseas public diplomacy campaigns. Hasbara.
This is not a fringe operation run by rogue diplomats. It is a line item in a national budget, larger than the entire annual budget of many Canadian federal departments.
At the same time, Israel’s Foreign Affairs Minister Gideon Sa’ar publicly celebrated the House of Commons’ passage of Bill C-9, the Combatting Hate Act—the same bill that the Canadian Civil Liberties Association warned could suppress protest, criminalize dissent, and enable pre-emptive restriction of expression before any offence is committed.
Ambassador Iddo Moed, Israel’s representative to Canada, stated publicly that his objective is to convince the Canadian government to “limit” certain “freedoms.” – Globalnews
One day after Moed and Consul General Idit Shamir met with Ontario Premier Doug Ford and his ministers—urging “concrete action”—Ford sought an emergency injunction to ban Toronto’s Al-Quds Day rally, a major pro-Palestine protest. Ontario Minister Lecce tweeted about the meeting and the injunction in the same message. The Israeli Toronto Consulate retweeted Ford’s video explanation of the attempt.
A court blocked the injunction. The judge affirmed that “the right to assemble and speak freely must be maintained in times of global conflict. Perhaps at no other time is the protection of our civil liberties more important.”
The legislation is still proceeding.
Vince Gasparro meeting with Jewish Security Network in Vancouver, discussing community safety initiatives.

The pattern is not confined to Queen’s Park. On May 13, 2026, Liberal MP Vince Gasparro posted publicly from Vancouver, announcing a “productive morning meeting” with the Jewish Security Network and community leaders.

The government deliverables he listed: doubling the Canada Community Security Program to $135 million, passing Bill C-9, and providing the Jewish Security Network with $10 million in direct funding.

He closed by thanking CJPAC—the Canadian Jewish Political Affairs Committee, the political action arm of the Centre for Israel and Jewish Affairs (CIJA)—for “leadership during my trip as well.”

What trip? When? Who paid? Journalists should ask these questions. Under Canada’s Foreign Influence Transparency Registry, they should appear somewhere.

In December 2025, Ontario MPP Michelle Cooper tabled Motion 58 to create a specialized hate crime prosecution unit in Ontario—providing police with the capacity to lay charges and improve conviction rates. The motion received strong support from CIJA, B’nai Brith Canada, and police services. It is moving through the legislature while Bill C-9 moves through Parliament. Two instruments. One direction.

This is what transnational repression looks like when it operates inside a democracy with a Charter of Rights. It does not arrive in the night. It arrives in a meeting, a tweet, a legal filing, a lobbying campaign. It arrives with the language of fighting hatred. And it targets, among others, Jewish Canadians whose opposition to Israeli government policy is being framed — by Israeli state ministries — as a form of antisemitism requiring restriction.

Named. Profiled. Targeted. On Canadian Soil.

Since at least 2023, Israel’s Ministry of Diaspora Affairs has been monitoring pro-Palestinian activities in Canada, issuing regular reports naming organizers and characterizing demonstrations as high-risk to compel security responses from Canadian authorities.
One report, published in October 2024, targeted former Ontario MPP Sarah Jama and independent journalist Samira Mohyeddin, profiling them alongside a list of violent attacks on Jewish institutions—implying their words were responsible for the latter.
The anonymous social media account “Leviathan” compiles screenshots from the social media profiles of Canadians who support Palestine and routes them to employers and police—explicitly to get people fired, arrested, or deported.
It describes itself as “the unseen shadow fighting Jihadis, Antisemites, Anarchists and other threats.”
Its content regularly includes racist anti-Palestinian and anti-Muslim language. Its posts are frequently shared and amplified by Consul General Idit Shamir.
A diplomat of a foreign state amplifying a campaign designed to get Canadian civilians fired, arrested, or deported. Not in a neighbouring country. In this city.
Canary Mission, owned by an Israeli non-profit organization called Megamot Shalom, maintains a blacklist of pro-Palestinian students and professors in Canada and the United States. U.S. Immigration and Customs Enforcement officers have used this list as a targeting list for harassment, detainment, and deportation proceedings. Israeli border authorities use it to deny entry to academics and activists.
There are Canadians on this list right now; their profiles compiled, their movements at risk of restriction by a foreign government—without charge, without trial, without appeal.
This is the mechanism my previous piece, The Battle-Tested State, described in structural terms: an administrative designation, not a conviction, routes through a compliance algorithm and suspends civic existence. Canary Mission is that mechanism made personal. It has names on it. Some of those names belong to people who live here.

The Surveillance Infrastructure Already Inside Canadian Policing

There is one more thread, and it runs directly through the computers and phones of Canadian police officers.

Citizen Lab, based at the University of Toronto, confirmed that NSO Group’s Pegasus spyware has been used to hack the phones of Palestinian human rights defenders. Citizen Lab also found that Israeli spyware was being used by authoritarian Gulf states to repress activists on Canadian soil. The Ontario Provincial Police has been linked to Paragon Solutions, an Israeli firm, through a Citizen Lab report published in March 2025. Edmonton police are using AI-powered facial recognition from Corsight AI—an Israeli company whose technology has been used, according to CBC, for mass surveillance in Gaza.

The RCMP has admitted to using tools with capabilities similar to Pegasus, which it calls “On-Device Investigative Tools.” Thirteen federal departments were using spyware as of 2023. When asked, CSIS and the RCMP will neither confirm nor deny whether they use Palantir—the AI and data analytics company already embedded in Canadian federal and provincial government procurement through a master supply agreement, whose tools were used in Israeli military operations in Gaza, and whose Canadian public pension funds are among its major shareholders.

AWZ Ventures, a Toronto-based company financing Israeli spyware firms, is led by former Israeli intelligence officials. One of its leading partners is former Canadian Prime Minister Stephen Harper.

The technology tested on the civilian population of Gaza is already inside Canadian policing. The bank being built to finance the next generation of this procurement—the Defence, Security and Resilience Bank, whose charter was negotiated in Montréal on March 26, 2026—explicitly finances dual-use AI and surveillance infrastructure. The DSRB is not building something new. It is scaling something already deployed. Something already proven on a captive civilian population. Something already running inside Canadian government systems.

The company central to all of it holds a $36.6 million contract with the Ontario Provincial Police and a $14 million contract with the Department of National Defence, while Canadian public pension funds hold its shares, and the government will not confirm or deny the full scope of its use.

What Canada Has Confirmed — and Done Nothing About

Here is what Canada’s own government has confirmed:

It confirmed elements of the Israeli disinformation campaign that created fake Canadian websites and hundreds of AI-generated social media accounts to spread anti-Muslim racism. Then it took no action.

It confirmed that foreign interference legislation—the Countering Foreign Interference Act—gives it tools to respond, including expelling diplomats and laying criminal charges. It has not used those tools in relation to Israel.

It redacted Israel’s name from Parliament’s foreign interference report at the Prime Minister’s direction.

Its standing committee studying Bill C-9 was forced to conclude its work after two days, at the government’s direction, despite more than 40 civil society organizations warning that the bill would suppress protest and criminalize dissent.

Its Arms Trade Treaty obligations require the Minister of Foreign Affairs to block military export permits when there is a substantial risk goods could be used to commit serious violations of international humanitarian law. The International Court of Justice found it plausible in January 2024 that Israel’s conduct in Gaza could constitute genocide.

The government’s response was to change its language and continue shipping.

The Sign Is Still There. And We Can See the Hands Holding It.

Alex Neve, Canada’s longtime human rights advocate, has written that international law is not broken. Our commitment to it is.

Alfred de Zayas, who served as UN Independent Expert on International Order and has tracked Canada’s UN voting record resolution by resolution for decades, puts it precisely: “One is tempted to think that international law no longer exists, that barbarism and the law of the jungle have taken over. But no, we must all persevere and reaffirm human values and the importance of international law.” His word for the alternative to accountability is complicity. Qui tacet consentire videtur. Silence implies consent.

Mark Carney said at Davos that middle powers must apply the same standards to allies and rivals. He said that looking away is not a passive act. He said Canada was taking the sign out of the window.

The sign is still there. And behind it, carefully documented, confirmed in part by his own government, and redacted at his own direction: the hand that put it there.

You Are Living Inside This Story

Who is the target? Palestinian Canadians, Muslim Canadians, Jewish anti-Zionist Canadians, student activists, independent journalists, and Canadian civilians who have no idea they are inside this story.

Who pays? Your taxes fund the OPP’s Palantir contract. Your pension may hold Palantir shares. Your neighbour’s name may be on Canary Mission. Your government confirmed the interference and did nothing. Your parliament has the foreign government’s name on a classified list and will not show it to you.

The Charter at 44 gives you tools. A court used one of them in March to block an injunction against a Toronto protest. The same government that celebrated the Charter’s anniversary tried to ban that protest the week before.
The first thing these systems require is that you not look. The second thing they require is that, having looked, you say nothing.

This is the invitation to do neither.

Further Reading

Stay mindful, sustainable, and open-minded

Smiling woman in red dress sitting on a white sofa, leaning on her hand.

Nancy Perin

Nancy is a caring individual with a background in sociology and a strong desire to connect people. She has improved workplaces and communities with her almost two decades of experience in management teams, human resources, coaching, and community project management. Nancy has also served on the board of directors of the Italian Personnel Managers Association and participated in a humanitarian mission to Dakar, Senegal, to support family centres.

Her intercultural love story sparked her interest in migration-relatedtopics and led her to launch @journeysta, a project that aims to strengthen cultural ties between Canada and Italy.

Nancy oversees the Gallery of Human Migration and believes in the possibility of creating caring communities that are involved in the processes of welcoming, acceptance, and integration. Join her on this journey of discovery and cultural exchange.

Stay Connected

Subscribe to Nancy’s e-newsletter and be among the first to learn about new articles …and more!

Woman smiling in a garden, sitting on a rock beside white flowers, enjoying the sunny day.